TCO and human hours for large deployments
lreed at boomerang.com
Wed Sep 19 20:50:27 UTC 2007
Thanks very much for that info.
That is very helpful!
Colin Paddock wrote:
> We have a somewhat largish mogilefs cluster, with 10 storage nodes and
> something like 100 million files, without counting replication, added to
> mogile to date (we deployed about two months ago now)
> It took two people about a month to deploy, but this also included:
> * Design of how we were going to set up the cluster
> * Racking the machines needed
> * Modifying our applications to use the mogile backend. (This required
> about two days of an engineer's time, on top of the two ops people
> dedicated to the project.)
> * Testing various db/config options with an eye towards performance of
> reads/writes. Testing lighty versus perlbal, etc.
> * Actually sitting down and learning how mogile works (and we're still a
> bit behind on that one :) )
> After the deployment, it's been fairly smooth, without too much
> maintenance. We've had to spend some time writing plug-ins for
> nagios/ganglia, but beyond that, it's been a low-maintenance cluster.
> We've also spent a good deal of time creating web-tool front ends for
> mogadm, but this was more in our spare time.
> Colin Paddock
> -----Original Message-----
> From: mogilefs-bounces at lists.danga.com
> [mailto:mogilefs-bounces at lists.danga.com] On Behalf Of Lance Reed
> Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2007 4:07 AM
> To: mogilefs at lists.danga.com
> Subject: TCO and human hours for large deployments
> I am working out the Total Cost for a large (er, scalable...) mogilefs
> deployment. The numbers for hardware are relatively easy depending on
> design. However, like all opensource initiatives, calculating the time
> / resources for administration by humans is tricky until you do it for
> awhile. Our company has plenty of experience using OpenSource tools for
> the majority of our needs, with the proprietary solution thrown in where
> applicable. So I was wondering if anyone who is attempting to setup a
> mogilefs storage setup, or who is using one now could shed some light on
> the subject. I figured initially, on a new deployment, about 60% of a
> single Administrators time would be taken up to maintain a large
> mogilefs cluster. I figure design and implementation would take much
> more than that (maybe 2 or 3 people to save time). I am comparing this
> to a couple proprietary solutions we have been looking at that are known
> to scale well into multi TB or even PB setup that are basically Scalable
> NAS solutions that use a "brick" mentality. The theory being that you
> pay upfront for stability or support if needed. But I am wondering if
> say 60% for the first year of learning how to maintain and grow a
> production mogilefs is close or not. Too high / low?
> Any thoughts or real work data would be great.
> Thanks all!!
CSI Cardiff, I'd like to see that. They'd be measuring the velocity of a kebab!"
More information about the mogilefs